South Carolina General Assembly
109th Session, 1991-1992
Journal of the Senate

Friday, May 8, 1992

(Local Session)

Indicates Matter Stricken
Indicates New Matter

The Senate assembled at 11:00 A.M., the hour to which it stood adjourned and was called to order by the ACTING PRESIDENT, Senator Senator PATTERSON.

REPORT RECEIVED

COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES FOR BOARDS

OF TRUSTEES OF STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES

MEMORANDUM

TO: Clerk of the Senate

Clerk of the House
FROM: Eugene C. Stoddard, Chairman
DATE: May 7, 1992
RE: Transcripts of Hearings

In compliance with the provisions of Act 119 of 1975, it is respectfully requested that the following information be printed in the Journals of the Senate and the House.

BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES

FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF

STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES

COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDING

SCREENING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, HELD IN ROOM 433, BLATT STATE OFFICE BUILDING, COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA, ON APRIL 9, 1992, COMMENCING AT THE HOUR OF 9:00 A.M.

MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE IN ATTENDANCE:
REPRESENTATIVE EUGENE C. STODDARD, CHAIRMAN
REPRESENTATIVE DANIEL E. MARTIN, SR., SECRETARY
SENATOR WARREN K. GIESE
REPRESENTATIVE JENNINGS G. McABEE
REPRESENTATIVE H. HOWELL CLYBORNE, JR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: WELL, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN IT'S NICE TO HAVE YOU WITH US AND WE'LL START NOW.

IN THE FIRST DISTRICT, WE HAVE NANCY J. CASH, WHO IS UNOPPOSED; SECOND DISTRICT, GEORGE R. STARNES, WHO IS UNOPPOSED; FOURTH, DISTRICT C. TYRONE GILLMORE, WHO IS UNOPPOSED; FIFTH DISTRICT, ANNE WALKER, WHO IS UNOPPOSED; AND THE SIXTH DISTRICT, WALTER SMITH, WHO IS UNOPPOSED. DO I HAVE A MOTION ON THESE UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES?

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: I MOVE THAT WE WAIVE SCREENING ON THE UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES.

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I SECOND THE MOTION.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THE MOTION IS MADE AND SECONDED THAT THE UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES WILL WAIVE SCREENING. WE APPRECIATE YOU COMING AND WE APPRECIATE THE GOOD JOB THAT Y'ALL ARE DOING. YOU MAY FEEL FREE TO LEAVE AT ANY TIME. YOU ARE ALREADY CERTIFIED AND YOU MAY SEEK SUPPORT, WHICH UNOPPOSED YOU DON'T NEED. NOW IN THE THIRD DISTRICT WE HAVE TWO CANDIDATES. FIRST, WE HAVE TIMOTHY D. ETSON. WOULD HE PLEASE COME FORWARD.

MR. ETSON, I'LL HAVE TO ASK YOU A FEW QUESTIONS BUT FIRST I'LL SWEAR YOU IN.

(TIMOTHY D. ETSON, CANDIDATE FOR THE THIRD DISTRICT ON THE LANDER COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR, I HAVE A CLEAN BILL OF HEALTH.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A SURE.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NONE WHATSOEVER.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO, I DO NOT.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: YOU MAY STEP DOWN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: NEXT WE HAVE MS. JEAN T. McFERRIN.

(JEAN T. McFERRIN, CANDIDATE FOR THE THIRD DISTRICT ON THE LANDER COLLEGE, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO, SIR.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES, SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO, SIR.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO, SIR.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF MS. McFERRIN? I BELIEVE YOU'RE SEEKING RE-ELECTION AREN'T YOU MS. McFERRIN?
A YES, SIR.
REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU, MA'AM.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: NEXT WE HAVE OPPOSITION IN THE AT-LARGE SEAT. THIS IS A VACANT SEAT. OUR FIRST CANDIDATE IS MARY D. MOORE.

(MARY D. MOORE, CANDIDATE FOR THE AT-LARGE SEAT ON THE LANDER COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO, I DON'T.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO, I DON'T.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF MS. MOORE?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU MA'AM.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: OUR NEXT CANDIDATE FOR THAT SEAT IS WILLIAM STEVENS.

(WILLIAM STEVENS, CANDIDATE FOR THE AT-LARGE SEAT ON THE LANDER COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, AS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q MR. STEVENS, DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO, I DO NOT.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU FOR COMING, MR. STEVENS.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: YOU ALL HAVE THEIR BACKGROUND INFORMATION AND, OF COURSE, I NOTICED SLED APPROVES ALL OF THEM. NONE OF THEM HAVE ANY RECORDS. DO I HEAR A MOTION?

REPRESENTATIVE CYLBORNE: I MOVE THAT THEY BE CERTIFIED, MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE McABEE: I SECOND THE MOTION.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THE MOTION MADE AND SECONDED THAT uYOU ALL BE CERTIFIED. WE FIND YOU QUALIFIED TO RUN. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. YOU MAY NOW COMMENCE TO SEEK PLEDGES. WE APPRECIATE ALL OF YOU COMING.

REPRESENTATIVE McABEE: I MOVE THAT THE COMMITTEE ADJOURN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. McABEE MOVES THAT THE COMMITTEE ADJOURN. THE AYES HAVE IT.

BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES

FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF

STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES

COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDING

SCREENING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, HELD IN ROOM 433, BLATT STATE OFFICE BUILDING, COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA, ON APRIL 16, 1992, COMMENCING AT THE HOUR OF 9:00 A.M.

MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE IN ATTENDANCE:
REPRESENTATIVE EUGENE C. STODDARD, CHAIRMAN
SENATOR ALEXANDER MACAULAY, VICE CHAIRMAN
REPRESENTATIVE DANIEL E. MARTIN, SR., SECRETARY
SENATOR WARREN K. GIESE
REPRESENTATIVE H. HOWELL CLYBORNE, JR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: LET ME INTRODUCE THE PANEL HERE THIS MORNING. SENATOR GIESE ON MY FAR LEFT, REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE NEXT AND THEN VICE-CHAIRMAN SENATOR MACAULAY, AND ON MY RIGHT REPRESENTATIVE DANNY MARTIN. WE HAVE SEVERAL CANDIDATES THIS MORNING WITHOUT OPPOSITION. WE HAVE RECEIVED ALL OF OUR REPORTS ON THEM, SLED AND OTHERWISE. AND NONE OF THEM HAVE ANY RECORDS OF ANY SORT.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. CLYBORNE.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: I MOVE THAT THOSE WITHOUT OPPOSITION BE CERTIFIED BY THIS PANEL.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. CLYBORNE MOVES THAT THOSE UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES BE CERTIFIED. IS THERE A SECOND?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. MARTIN SECONDS. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT. THAT WOULD BE CHERYL D. WHIPPER, JOEL H. SMITH, WILLIAM J. DAY, MERL F. CODE, JOHN V. PRICE, MARIE M. LAND, AND TIMOTHY N. DANGERFIELD OF THE COLLEGE OF CHARLESTON. AND ON THE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY IT WOULD BE MELVYN BERLINSKY, PATRICIA T. SMITH, DR. CHARLES B. HANNA, DR. COTESWORTH P. FISHBURNE, AND DR. E. CONYERS O'BRYAN. AND THE WIL LOU GRAY OPPORTUNITY SCHOOL IT WOULD BE WILHELMINA MCBRIDE, DR. MARVIN EFRON, AND OLIVE F. WILSON. NOW WE GET BACK TO THOSE WITH OPPOSITION. WE CERTAINLY APPRECIATE YOU LADIES AND GENTLEMEN SERVING. WE REALIZE YOU DID A GREAT SACRIFICE. AND WE REALLY APPRECIATE THE JOB YOU'RE DOING AND WE CERTAINLY APPRECIATE YOU COMING THIS MORNING.

FIRST, WE HAVE THE CITADEL BOARD. ONE SEAT VACANT WITH TWO CANDIDATES. DAVID S. BOYD.

MR. BOYD: YES, SIR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: WOULD YOU STEP TO THE PODIUM PLEASE SIR.

MR. BOYD: YES.

(DAVID S. BOYD, CANDIDATE FOR BOARD OF VISITORS FOR THE CITADEL, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO I DON'T.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A I WILL.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q GENTLEMEN, DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE CANDIDATE?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q I HAVE ALWAYS BEEN FASCINATED BY THE LOYALTY AND THE ESPRIT DE CORPS THAT THE CITADEL GRADUATES HAVE AND WHAT IS YOUR CONNECTION WITH THE CITADEL AND YOUR EXPERIENCE WITH THE CITADEL?
A WELL, SIR. I GRADUATED IN 1962. DURING THE EARLIER PART OF MY CAREER, I WAS WITH DANIEL CONSTRUCTION AND IN THE ARMY AND I MOVED AROUND A LITTLE BIT AND SETTLED BACK IN SOUTH CAROLINA IN THE EARLY '71-'73 PERIOD. I BECAME ACTIVE IN THE ALUMNI ASSOCIATION IN ABOUT 1973. THE FIRST OFFICE I HELD WAS DISTRICT DIRECTOR IN GREENVILLE, THE SECOND OFFICE WAS A MEMBER OF THE ATHLETIC ADVISORY COMMITTEE AND I WAS ELECTED TO THE VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE ASSOCIATION WHICH IS PRESIDENT ELECT AND ENDED UP AS PRESIDENT OF THE ALUMNI ASSOCIATION. THE FOLLOWING YEAR I WAS ELECTED PRESIDENT OF THE BRIGADIER, WHICH IS OUR ATHLETIC FUND RAISER. THAT WAS 1983. IN 1987, FALL OF 1986, I RAN FOR THE ALUMNI SEAT ON THE BOARD OF VISITORS. I AM CURRENTLY SERVING AS ALUMNI MEMBER AND CANNOT SUCCEED MYSELF IN THAT CAPACITY.
Q ONE OF THE BIG QUESTIONS, OF COURSE, ABOUT THE CITADEL IS WHETHER IT WILL BE FORCED TO INTEGRATE ITS STUDENT BODY. WHAT IS YOUR FEELING ON THE POSSIBLE FUTURE FOR THE CITADEL IF THE LAW REQUIRES THE INTEGRATION OF THE SCHOOL?
A SENATOR, FIRST I'D LIKE TO SAY THAT I SUPPORT THE PRESENT POLICY BECAUSE I BELIEVE THAT IT'S A TIME PROOF TESTED POLICY AND HAS TURNED A LOT OF GREAT MEN OUT OVER ITS HISTORY. IF THE LAW IS CHANGED AT THE SUPREME COURT LEVEL, THEN I WILL SUPPORT WHAT THE LAW SAYS.

SENATOR GIESE: THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. BOYD, DID YOU EVER LIVE IN FOUNTAIN INN?

MR. BOYD: NO SIR. I HAVE SOME RELATIVES THAT DID AT ONE TIME.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THIS COMPANY YOU'RE WITH, WHO USED TO HAVE THAT?

MR. BOYD: A FELLOW NAMED JOHN WOOD AND I STARTED IT IN 1974 AND HE RETIRED IN 1989.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: I THOUGHT I MET YOU WHEN DISPOSO WAS BUILT.

MR. BOYD: YES, SIR YOU DID. WE BUILT ALL THREE PHASES.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU SIR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: NEXT, WE HAVE MR. W. E. JENKINSON, III.

(W. E. JENKINSON, III, CANDIDATE FOR BOARD OF VISITORS FOR THE CITADEL, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A I DO NOT.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES, SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO, SIR.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

SENATOR GIESE: I'D LIKE TO ASK THE SAME QUESTION, MR. CHAIRMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SURE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q WHAT IS YOUR BACKGROUND IN WORKING WITH CITADEL OR BEING A STUDENT THERE, ETC.?
A SENATOR, I WENT TO THE CITADEL AND GRADUATED IN 1968. NOT BY A WHOLE LOT OF CHOICE. I WAS BORN INTO THE SCHOOL. MY GREAT-GRANDFATHER ATTENDED THERE, DID NOT GRADUATE BECAUSE THE SCHOOL CLOSED. MY FATHER ATTENDED THERE AND PLAYED FOOTBALL AND GRADUATED. MY TWO BROTHERS ATTENDED AND GRADUATED. MY UNCLE, MY COUSINS. IT IS A FAMILY TRADITION. IT IS AS MUCH A PART OF ME AS MY FAMILY IS IN A SENSE. AFTER GRADUATION, I PRACTICED LAW IN KINGSTREE. I'VE BEEN ACTIVE IN THE ALUMNI ASSOCIATION. I ATTEND MANY EVENTS AND HAVE BEEN VERY ACTIVE IN THE AFFAIRS. I'VE BEEN A SPONSOR FOR MANY YEARS OF THE CITADEL LEGISLATIVE BARBECUE. HARDLY A DAY GOES BY THAT I'M NOT INVOLVED IN ONE WAY, SHAPE, OR FORM WITH THE SCHOOL, THROUGH MY FAMILY OR FRIENDS, CLASSMATES, OR ACTIVITIES WITH THE SCHOOL.
Q AND WHAT WOULD YOUR POSITION BE IF THEY, I GUESS INTEGRATE IS THE WRONG WORD, CO-EDUCATE. COULD IT FLY?
A I DON'T WANT TO REPEAT WORD FOR WORD WHAT MR. BOYD HAS SAID. BUT I THINK THAT ANY CITADEL GRADUATE, ESPECIALLY BEING A LAWYER, WOULD HAVE TO SAY THAT I SUPPORT THE SCHOOL IN THE PRESENT ENVIRONMENT, IN ONLY HAVING MEN ATTEND. BUT LIKEWISE, AS A LAWYER, I ALSO RESPECT WHAT THE LAW OF THE LAND MAY BE. AND THE VMI CASE, AS YOU KNOW, IS FOLLOWING ITS COURSE THROUGH THE COURTS, WAS ARGUED IN THE FOURTH CIRCUIT LAST WEEK. A CASE I'VE FOLLOWED VERY CLOSELY AS THE UNDERGRADUATES HAVE AND IF THE COURTS DETERMINE THAT WE WILL ACCEPT WOMEN, I WILL SUPPORT THAT FULLY AND DO WHATEVER I FEEL IS THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITIZENS OF SOUTH CAROLINA AND PARTICULARLY TO SEE THAT WHATEVER IS DONE IS DONE IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THIS STATE AND THE SCHOOL. WE HAVE SURVIVED MANY CHANGES AND MANY CIRCUMSTANCES SINCE 1842 AND I ASSURE YOU THAT WE WILL CONTINUE TO DO THAT FOR THE NEXT HUNDREDS OF YEARS.

SENATOR GIESE: I'VE BEEN A GREAT ADMIRER OF THE CITADEL PEOPLE. I HAVE NEVER SEEN SUCH A STRONG SUPPORT THAT THEY SHOW FOR EACH OTHER AND THEIR LOYALTY. I'VE GOT A GRANDSON AND IF THE CITADEL IS STILL THERE I HOPE HE CAN MAKE IT IN.

MR. JENKINSON: SENATOR, THAT'S JUST WHY IT'S SO GOOD FOR THIS STATE. THAT'S WHY WE'RE SO PROUD OF IT.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU SIR.

MR. JENKINSON: THANK YOU MR. CHAIRMAN.

SENATOR MACAULAY: MR. CHAIRMAN, I WOULD MAKE THE SAME MOTION SINCE BOTH OF THE CANDIDATES ARE HERE THIS MORNING AND THERE APPARENTLY IS NO QUESTION ABOUT THE QUALIFICATIONS, THAT WE GO AHEAD AND CERTIFY THEM THIS MORNING.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: DO I HEAR A SECOND?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR MACAULAY MAKES THE MOTION THAT WE CERTIFY THE CANDIDATES AND FIND THEM QUALIFIED, SECONDED BY MR. MARTIN. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU GENTLEMEN. NEXT WE HAVE THE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA IN THE THIRD DISTRICT, A GENTLEMAN BY THE NAME OF MILFORD J. COOPER.

(MILFORD J. COOPER, CANDIDATE FOR THE THIRD DISTRICT LAY SEAT ON THE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NOT TO MY KNOWLEDGE.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A I WILL.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I HAVE ONE.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. MARTIN.

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: DO YOU HAVE ANY OBJECTIONS TO YOUR SON DOING AN EXCELLENT JOB AS A REPRESENTATIVE IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES?

MR. COOPER: I DON'T OBJECT.

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I'M SATISFIED.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: I THINK HE'S TRYING TO PROVE THAT HE CAN DO A BETTER JOB THAN HIS FATHER. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

SENATOR GIESE: CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q WHAT PARTICULAR INTEREST DO YOU HAVE IN THE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY?
A WELL, I HAVE BEEN ASSOCIATED WITH THE BETTER HEALTH CARE SINCE 1972, ABOUT 20 YEARS, AND THAT'S ONE REASON I GOT INVOLVED IN POLITICS, TO IMPROVE HEALTH CARE CONDITIONS IN MY AREA. I LIVE BETWEEN TWO LARGE TOWNS, GREENVILLE AND ANDERSON, BUT YET WE WERE HAVING A HARD TIME FINDING DOCTORS IN PELZER AND PIEDMONT, SENATOR MACAULAY. SO I'M IN POLITICS TO IMPROVE HEALTH CONDITIONS AND WE TRIED TO IMPROVE FACILITIES IN 1989 AND 1990 ON THE MEDICAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE.

SENATOR GIESE: THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

THANK YOU MR. COOPER.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THE OTHER CANDIDATE IS JACK F. MCINTOSH. I DON'T BELIEVE HE IS HERE. WHAT IS THE PLEASURE OF THE COMMITTEE?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: IS THERE ANY QUESTION ABOUT HIM PROPERLY BEING NOTIFIED?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: NO, HE WAS PROPERLY NOTIFIED. HE IS AN INCUMBENT. THE ONLY PROBLEM I'LL HAVE WITH IT IS IF WE HEARD HE HAD AN ACCIDENT ON THE WAY DOWN OR SOMETHING.

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: WHAT IS THE USUAL COURSE OF ACTION?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: WELL, WE HAVE IN CASES WHERE THEY HAVE MEDICAL PROBLEMS OR FAMILY TRIPS, WE HAVE DELAYED THEIR HEARING UNTIL ANOTHER DATE. WE'LL HAVE ONE MORE SCREENING, WELL TWO MORE I GUESS. WE'LL HAVE ONE MORE NEXT THURSDAY, AND THEN WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO ADVERTISE THIS WEEKEND FOR TWO NEWLY CREATED SEATS. THEY ARE NOT NEW SEATS, THEY USED TO BE ALUMNI MEMBERS OF THE OPPORTUNITY SCHOOL AND THE GOVERNOR JUST SIGNED A BILL TO LET THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY ELECT THEM. SO WE'LL HAVE TO ADVERTISE FOR THAT. WHATEVER THE COMMITTEE'S ACTION MAY DESIRE.

SENATOR GIESE: CHAIRMAN, I NOTICE HE IS A PRACTICING ATTORNEY WHICH COULD MEAN HE HAD SOME CONFLICT AND I WONDER IF WE COULDN'T CERTIFY THE GENTLEMAN WE JUST SPOKE WITH AND THEN MAKE ONE EFFORT TO CONTACT HIM TO SEE HIS REASONS. HE MAY JUST NOT HAVE AN INTEREST ANYMORE.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE MOVES THAT WE CERTIFY MR. COOPER AND DELAY UNTIL NEXT WEEK ANY ACTION ON MR. MCINTOSH. DO I HEAR A SECOND?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I SECOND

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. MARTIN SECONDS. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU FOR COMING THIS MORNING.

THE MOTION HAS BEEN MADE THAT THE COMMITTEE ADJOURN. THE AYES HAVE IT.

BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES

FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF

STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES

COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDING

SCREENING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, HELD IN ROOM 433, BLATT STATE OFFICE BUILDING, COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA, ON APRIL 23, 1992, COMMENCING AT THE HOUR OF 9:00 A.M.

MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE IN ATTENDANCE:
REPRESENTATIVE EUGENE C. STODDARD, CHAIRMAN
REPRESENTATIVE DANIEL E. MARTIN, SR., SECRETARY
SENATOR WARREN K. GIESE
SENATOR JOE WILSON
REPRESENTATIVE H. HOWELL CLYBORNE, JR.
REPRESENTATIVE JENNINGS G. MCABEE

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THE COMMITTEE WILL COME TO ORDER. FIRST ON THE AGENDA THIS MORNING IS A CANDIDATE FROM THE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA WHO GOT DELAYED IN ROUTE AND GOT HERE AFTER WE ADJOURNED LAST WEEK. IF MR. MCINTOSH WOULD TAKE THE STAND.

JACK MCINTOSH, CANDIDATE FOR THE THIRD DISTRICT LAY SEAT ON THE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A I WILL.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NONE AT ALL.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NONE.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF MR. MCINTOSH?

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: MR. MCINTOSH.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE:

Q WHAT IS YOUR PHILOSOPHY ABOUT WHAT A BOARD MEMBER SHOULD BE IN TERMS OF DAY-TO-DAY OPERATIONS AND POLICIES?
A WELL, AS A GOVERNING BOARD YOU ELECT RESPONSIBLE PEOPLE, YOU SET POLICY AND DIRECTION, AND THEN YOU REVIEW THEIR PERFORMANCES. YOU SEE WHETHER OR NOT THEY ARE CARRYING THAT OUT IN A FISCALLY SOUND WAY AND IF THEY ARE ACHIEVING THE OBJECTIVES OF THE INSTITUTION YOU SERVE AND YOU GRADE THEM ACCORDINGLY. AND THERE IS A LIMIT, OF COURSE. YOU AREN'T THERE TO RUN IT YOU'RE THERE TO SELECT PEOPLE WHO WILL AND YOU HAVE TO STAY OUT OF THEIR AREA.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: THAT'S MY QUESTION, THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: MR. MCINTOSH?

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN:

Q HOW MANY MEETINGS HAVE YOU MISSED IN THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS?
A I EXPECTED THAT QUESTION IN VIEW OF THE FACT THAT I MISSED THIS ONE LAST WEEK. I HAVEN'T MISSED ANY. I HAVEN'T EVEN BEEN LATE FOR ANY. I WANT TO APOLOGIZE TO YOU FOR WHAT HAPPENED LAST WEEK. I DID LEAVE ANDERSON AROUND 6:30 AND GOT CAUGHT BEHIND SCHOOL BUSES IN ANDERSON AND LAURENS COUNTY. AND WHEN I GOT HERE I COULDN'T FIND A PARKING PLACE. I CAME DOWN LAST NIGHT AND SPENT THE NIGHT.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THAT'S QUITE ALRIGHT. WE ACCEPT YOUR APOLOGY, I CAN UNDERSTAND IT, IT'S HAPPENED TO ME MANY TIMES.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? THANK YOU SIR.

MR. MCINTOSH: GENTLEMEN, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: YES, SIR. WE APPRECIATE YOU COMING. MR. JOEL H. SMITH, COLLEGE OF CHARLESTON. MR SMITH, I BELIEVE YOU WERE OUT OF STATE LAST WEEK. YOU ARE UNOPPOSED. HOW LONG HAVE YOU SERVED THERE?

MR. SMITH: FOR FOUR YEARS. I WAS ELECTED ON THE INITIAL CREATION OF THE BOARD OF THE COLLEGE OF CHARLESTON.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. CLYBORNE.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: SEEING HOW HE IS UNOPPOSED AND OUR RULES ALLOW FOR THAT I MOVE THAT WE CERTIFY HIM.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. CLYBORNE MOVES THAT WE WAIVE SCREENING ON THE GENTLEMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE MCABEE: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. MCABEE SECONDS. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT. THANK YOU SIR.

MR. SMITH: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: WE FIND YOU QUALIFIED.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: MR. CHAIRMAN, I WOULD MAKE THAT SAME MOTION ABOUT MR. MCINTOSH. DIDN'T WE CERTIFY THE OTHER GENTLEMAN LAST WEEK?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: YES SIR. YOU'D LIKE TO FIND HIM QUALIFIED. IS THERE A SECOND?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE. MR. MCINTOSH WAS FOUND QUALIFIED. YOU MAY SEEK A PLEDGE.

WE HAVE SEVERAL UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES ON THE WINTHROP BOARD. WE HAD THREE CANDIDATES BUT ONE DROPPED OUT SO WE HAVE TWO CANDIDATES FOR TWO SEATS. IS MR. GAHAGAN HERE?

MR. GAHAGAN: YES SIR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: IS MS. SAVAGE HERE? YOU WANT THE SAME MOTION ON THESE?

REPRESENTATIVE MCABEE: YES SIR IF THEY MEET ALL THE OTHER QUALIFICATIONS?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: CORRECT.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THE MOTION HAS BEEN MADE AND SECONDED THAT WE WAIVE SCREENING ON THESE UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT.

THANK YOU FOR COMING AND WE APPRECIATE YOUR DEDICATION AND SERVICE.

NEXT, WE HAVE FRANCIS MARION. WE HAVE THE FIRST DISTRICT, MICHAEL MURPHREE; SECOND DISTRICT, LORRAINE KNIGHT; WE'LL SKIP OVER THE THIRD DISTRICT FOR THE TIME BEING; FOURTH DISTRICT, SEAT 7 H. RANDALL DOZIER, SEAT 8, ROBERT E. LANFORD, JR.; FIFTH DISTRICT, TRACY L. EGGLESTON; SIXTH DISTRICT, WILLIAM W. COLEMAN, JR.; AND THE AT-LARGE SEAT, M. RUSSELL HOLLIDAY, JR. THOSE WHOSE NAMES WE CALLED ARE UNOPPOSED. DO I HAVE A SIMILAR MOTION?

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: SAME MOTION.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT.

WE FIND YOU QUALIFIED, YOU ARE UNOPPOSED. YOU MAY LEAVE AT ANY TIME.

NEXT WE HAVE THE THIRD DISTRICT. WE HAVE A CONTEST THERE. WE HAVE WILLIAM A. COLLINS, WOULD HE PLEASE COME TO THE MICROPHONE.

(WILLIAM A. COLLINS, CANDIDATE FOR THE THIRD DISTRICT ON THE FRANCIS MARION BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: YES, SIR MR. MARTIN.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN:

Q ARE YOU AN INCUMBENT?
A YES, SIR.
Q DO YOU RECALL HOW MANY, IF ANY, MEETINGS YOU HAVE MISSED IN THE LAST TWO YEARS?
A I HAVE MISSED TWO.
Q AND HOW OFTEN DOES THE BOARD MEET?
A IT MEETS FOUR TIMES A YEAR NORMALLY.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THOSE MEETINGS ARE MORE OR LESS QUARTERLY?

MR. COLLINS: YES SIR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN? THANK YOU MR. COLLINS.

FOR THE SAME SEAT WE HAVE ANOTHER CANDIDATE, LEE MILLER.

(LEE MILLER, CANDIDATE FOR THE THIRD DISTRICT ON THE FRANCIS MARION BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NONE THAT I AM AWARE OF.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A I WILL.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NONE THAT I AM AWARE OF. I AM ON THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE SRP FEDERAL CREDIT UNION BUT I DO NOT CONSIDER THAT A CONFLICT.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF MR. MILLER?

REPRESENTATIVE MCABEE: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: YES MR. MCABEE.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE MCABEE:

Q MR. MILLER, I NOTICED THAT YOU WENT TO THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA. DO YOU HAVE AN PRIOR OR CURRENT CONNECTIONS WITH FRANCIS MARION COLLEGE?
A I DO NOT.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

THANK YOU MR. MILLER. OUR NEXT CANDIDATES THAT ARE OPPOSED ARE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE. WE HAVE TWO SEATS VACANT AND WE HAVE EIGHT CANDIDATES. WE'LL GO ALPHABETICALLY. FIRST, WE'D LIKE FOR MR. BREVARD TO COME FORWARD. HE' NOT PRESENT. GEORGE S. CHENAULT.

(GEORGE S. CHENAULT, CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NONE THAT I AM AWARE OF.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A I WILL.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A THE ONLY CURRENT BOARD THAT I AM SERVING ON IS A HEALTH PROVIDING BOARD IN THE BEAUFORT AREA AND I DON'T THINK THAT WOULD PRESENT A CONFLICT.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NONE.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF MR. CHENAULT?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q MR. CHENAULT, I DON'T THINK IT IS ANY UNKEPT SECRET BUT IT APPEARS THAT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE HAS BEEN IN TURMOIL FOR QUITE A PERIOD OF TIME. THERE HAS BEEN A CHANGE IN THE LEADERSHIP OF THE BOARD. WHAT WOULD YOU PROPOSE TO DO TO BRING SOME STABILITY TO THE SITUATION?
A WELL, ONE THING I'LL TELL YOU FIRST OF ALL SIR, IS THAT MY REAL KNOWLEDGE OF WHAT IS GOING ON THERE COMES FROM THE PRESS. AND I'M NOT SURE THAT IS A SOURCE THAT I WANT TO USE TO START MAKING JUDGMENTS ABOUT WHAT SHOULD BE DONE. JUST SPEAKING VERY GENERALLY, I WOULD THINK THOUGH THAT STRONG LEADERSHIP WOULD BE THE FIRST PRIORITY TO CORRECT WHAT I PERCEIVE AS PROBLEMS THAT I HAVE READ ABOUT FROM THE PRESS. THE FACT THAT THE LEADERSHIP HAS CHANGED AS YOU INDICATED. JUST SPEAKING GENERALLY, AS I SAID, I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE FACTS ARE. BUT FROM WHAT I'VE READ IN THE PAPER, I THINK THAT STRONG LEADERSHIP WOULD BE THE FIRST STEP TOWARDS CORRECTING WHAT HAVE BEEN PERCEIVED PROBLEMS AT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE.
Q ARE YOU SAYING THAT THE LEADERSHIP SHOULD BE AT, LET'S SAY THE PRESIDENT LEVEL, OR ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT THE BOARD ITSELF?
A I'M TALKING ABOUT, WELL THE BOARD FIRST, BUT AFTER THAT THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE INSTITUTION UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE BOARD. I'M THINKING SPECIFICALLY NOW THE LEADERSHIP MEANING ADMINISTRATION, THE PRESIDENT OF THE INSTITUTION.
Q I'VE BEEN TO CAMPUS MANY, MANY TIMES, AND THE CAMPUS HAS SOME REALLY FLAGSHIP BUILDINGS. GENERALLY SPEAKING, THE STUDENT BODY, IN MY OPINION, LIVES IN DORMITORIES THAT IN MOST CASES ARE PRETTY OUTDATED, THE PLUMBING IS INCREDIBLE. STUDENTS WERE ABOUT TO MOVE IN DORMITORIES THAT WERE SO BAD PARENTS GOT TOGETHER AND CLEANED THEM UP. WHAT DO YOU THINK THE ROLE OF THE BOARD IS IN THAT KIND OF SITUATION?
A FIRST OF ALL, SIR, I ATTENDED SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE THIRTY PLUS YEARS AGO. AT THAT TIME, THE SERIOUS PROBLEM WAS UNDER FUNDING. IT'S MY OPINION THAT HAS CONTINUED TO BE A PROBLEM BUT I DON'T KNOW THAT FOR A FACT BECAUSE I'M NOT THAT INTIMATELY INVOLVED. BUT IT DOES APPEAR TO ME THAT THE FUNDING PRIORITY HAS NOT BEEN WHAT IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN FOR THAT INSTITUTION. HERE AGAIN, I THINK THE LEADERSHIP WOULD MAKE SURE THAT RESOURCES THAT ARE AVAILABLE ARE USED EFFICIENTLY TO ADDRESS THE PROBLEMS THAT YOU ARE DISCUSSING HERE.
Q AND LAST BUT NOT LEAST, I JUST NOTICED IN THE NEWSPAPER RECENTLY THE SAT ENTRANCE SCORES WENT FROM CLEMSON AT 1018 DOWN TO SOUTH CAROLINA STATE AT 700, IN SOME SMALL NUMBER, 715. I HAVE SPENT MY LIFE IN EDUCATION. TO EQUATE A 715 WITH 1018 IS A TREMENDOUS DIFFERENCE IN STUDENTS CAPABILITY AS EVIDENCED BY THAT ONE MEASURE. WHAT WOULD YOU DO TO HANDLE THAT SITUATION?
A I DON'T THINK THERE IS ANY MAGIC FORMULA FOR THAT SIR. THERE IS A DISPARITY AND I READ ALSO IN THE STATE NEWSPAPER, PROBABLY THE SAME ARTICLE YOU READ, AND AM CONCERNED ABOUT THAT DISPARITY IN THE SCORES. I THINK THAT THAT'S AN ISSUE THAT MUST BE ADDRESSED LONG-RANGE, YOU CAN'T ADDRESS THAT ONLY AT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE. YOU HAVE TO ADDRESS THAT WITH STUDENTS AS THEY BEGIN SCHOOL IN THE EARLY YEARS. BECAUSE THE SCORES THEY ACHIEVE ARE REFLECTED TO SOME EXTENT OF THE TRAINING THEY HAVE RECEIVED IN PRIOR YEARS. I THINK YOU AND I BOTH KNOW THAT MANY OF THESE STUDENTS WHO ATTEND SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE, WHICH IS PREDOMINANTLY A BLACK INSTITUTION, EVEN TODAY HAVE COME FROM CIRCUMSTANCES THAT ARE LESS THAN MEETING NORMAL STANDARDS OF JOBS FOR PARENTS. SO YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT AN IMPACT THAT HAS COME OVER THE YEARS AND THERE IS NO MAGIC FORMULA. YOU CAN'T SAY SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE IS TOTALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR THOSE SCORES. I THINK THOSE ARE RESPONSIBILITIES THAT COME FROM PARENTS INABILITIES TO PROVIDE ADEQUATELY FOR YOUNGSTERS OVER MANY YEARS. AND THE KINDS OF EDUCATION THESE YOUNGSTERS HAVE RECEIVED OVER THE YEARS. I AM CONCERNED AND I THINK IT NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED. I THINK IT NEEDS TO BE ADDED AT THE COLLEGE LEVEL, PROBABLY SOME EFFORT WITH REMEDIATION TO HELP THOSE YOUNGSTERS BY THE TIME THEY TAKE THE SAT SO THAT AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE THEY CAN BE IMPROVED. BUT I THINK WE HAVE TO LOOK BEYOND THE COLLEGE AND BACK INTO THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? THANK YOU MR. CHENAULT.

NEXT WE HAVE WILLIS H. CROSBY.

(WILLIS H. CROSBY, CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A I DO NOT.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

SENATOR GIESE: YES.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q I READ ONE OF THE REPORTS THAT THE LEGISLATIVE AUDIT COUNCIL THAT REVIEWED SOME PROGRAMS AT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE AND THERE IS SOME QUESTION, I THINK THAT PROBABLY THE NEWSPAPER JUST RECENTLY HAD A LITTLE ARTICLE ABOUT IT, BUT I READ THE AUDIT COUNCIL REPORT. THERE SEEMS TO BE SOME FISCAL PROBLEM ABOUT MANAGING SOME OF THE DIFFERENT FUNDS THAT YOU HAVE, I AM THINKING SPECIFICALLY OF THE ATHLETIC DEPARTMENT FOUNDATION THAT YOU HAVE. WHAT WOULD YOU DO AS A MEMBER OF THE BOARD TO ADDRESS SOME OF THOSE FINANCIAL PROBLEMS?
A FIRST OF ALL, AS A RESPONSIBLE BOARD MEMBER I WOULD ATTEMPT TO SEEK WHAT THE SITUATION IS. I THINK MANY TIMES WHAT COMES OUT IN THE PRESS AND SO FORTH IS DIFFERENT FROM WHAT THE SITUATION MAY BE. I WOULD NEED TO BECOME AWARE OF THAT AND I THINK THAT ME BEING A BOARD MEMBER I WOULD HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY TO ATTEMPT TO ADDRESS THE MATTER.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?
REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: THANK YOU SIR.

OUR NEXT CANDIDATE IS SAM GLOVER.

(SAM GLOVER, CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q MR. GLOVER, DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO SIR.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO SIR.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

SENATOR GIESE: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q MR. GLOVER, WHY DO YOU FEEL YOU'D LIKE TO BE A MEMBER OF THIS BOARD?
A WELL, I CERTAINLY THINK I CAN HELP SOUTH CAROLINA STATE OUT. YOU PROBABLY NOTICED ON MY RESUME OR VITAE THERE, THAT I SPENT TWENTY-TWO YEARS BASICALLY IN THAT AREA. I HAVE TWO DEGREES FROM THERE, A B.S. AND M.S. DEGREE. IN ADDITION TO THAT, I TAUGHT ROTC THERE FOR FOUR YEARS MOST RECENTLY, FROM '86 THROUGH '89. DURING THAT TIME I HAD THE CHANCE TO OBSERVE THE SCHOOL FROM AN INSIDE SITUATION AS A FACULTY MEMBER. I GOT A CHANCE TO COMPARE THAT TO MY STUDENT LIFE THERE. I OBSERVED THAT HERE RECENTLY THINGS HAVE SEEMED TO GOTTEN OUT OF HAND FROM THE STANDPOINT OF I THINK WE'RE MORE OR LESS GOING TO THE HIGH ENROLLMENT NOW RATHER THAN PRODUCING QUALITY STUDENTS. I THINK THE FOCUS SHOULD BE ON PRODUCING QUALITY STUDENTS AND NOT NUMBERS. YOU PROBABLY NOTICED THERE THAT I HAVE SEVERAL BUSINESSES. I'M CONCERNED WHEN A STUDENT FROM SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE COMES TO ME AND NEEDS A JOB AS A CASHIER, AS AN EXAMPLE, AT MY MCDONALD'S. WE NEED TO BE FOCUSED ON PRODUCING HIGH QUALITY STUDENTS. IF WE WANT TO HAVE A HIGHER ENROLLMENT THEN WE MUST DO SOMETHING TO SUPPLEMENT THE LIMITED FUNDING THAT WE ARE PRESENTLY GETTING FROM THE STATE GOVERNMENT. I DON'T THINK ENOUGH FOCUS IS BEING DONE IN THAT PARTICULAR AREA AT THIS TIME FROM THE KNOWLEDGE THAT I HAVE. I CERTAINLY THINK WITH MY BUSINESS BACKGROUND AND EXPERIENCE I HAVE FROM WORKING THERE I COULD BE AN ASSET TO THE BOARD AS FAR AS SETTING POLICIES UP.
Q WHAT IS THE BIGGEST DIFFERENCE, YOU SAID THAT YOU HAVE TWO DEGREES FROM SOUTH CAROLINA STATE, FROM THE TIME YOU WERE THERE AS A STUDENT UNTIL YOU HAD THE EXPERIENCE AS A FACULTY MEMBER AND NOW? WHAT'S THE BIGGEST CHANGE?
A WELL, I THINK THE FOCUS THEN SEEMED TO BE MORE ON A QUALITY EDUCATION AND I JUST NOTICE A CHANGE IN THAT HERE RECENTLY THE INDICATION HAS BEEN ON 'WE HAVE X NUMBER OF STUDENTS'. THE CONCERN THAT WE HAVE A HIGHER NUMBER OF STUDENTS. TRYING TO EDUCATE THE MASSES AND, IN MY OPINION, I DON'T KNOW WHETHER OR NOT THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD BE GOING AFTER. I THINK WE SHOULD BE TRYING TO PRODUCE QUALITY STUDENTS AND THEN PRODUCE A MASSIVE NUMBER OF QUALITY STUDENTS IF THAT'S WHAT WE CAN DO WITH THE FUNDING THAT'S AVAILABLE. BUT IF THERE IS LIMITED FUNDING THEN WE PROBABLY SHOULD BE LOOKING AT LIMITED ENROLLMENT. I AM NOT SURE RATHER WE SHOULD DO THAT OR NOT WITHOUT LOOKING AT THE SITUATION. BUT AS IT STANDS NOW, IT APPEARS THAT IS WHAT NEEDS TO HAPPEN.
Q I AM INTERESTED IN YOUR QUALITY STUDENT SITUATION. I THINK WE ALL TRY TO DO THAT AT COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, BUT HOW WOULD YOU SUGGEST THE SCHOOL GO ABOUT TURNING OUT HIGHER QUALITY STUDENTS?
A WELL I THINK IT IS CENTERED AROUND THE ENROLLMENT PROGRAM AND I GUESS THE RECRUITING PROGRAM. IN ORDER TO RECRUIT BETTER STUDENTS THEN YOU HAVE GOT TO HAVE THE RIGHT KIND OF PROGRAM IN PLACE, A PROGRAM THAT IS GOING TO ATTRACT THE BETTER STUDENTS TO ATTEND YOUR PARTICULAR INSTITUTION AND I'M NOT SURE WE HAVE THAT IN PLACE RIGHT NOW. AND THAT'S WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT. I THINK THAT HAS SOMETHING TO DO WITH THE DISPARITY BETWEEN CLEMSON WITH A THOUSAND AND SOMETHING SAT AND SOUTH CAROLINA 714 AS I RECALL. AND THAT HAS SOME BEARING ON THAT.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

THANK YOU SIR. NEXT WE HAVE JANETTE HENRY.

(JANETTE HENRY, CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NONE TO MY KNOWLEDGE.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES I WOULD.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO I DO NOT.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO I DO NOT.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE LADY?

SENATOR WILSON: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR WILSON.

SENATOR WILSON: I'D LIKE TO COMMEND MS. HENRY ON THE FINE PRESENTATION WHICH YOU HAD ATTACHED, WHICH WAS THE PROPOSED TESTIMONY. IT CERTAINLY INDICATES A SINCERE AND DEEP DESIRE TO SERVE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY.

MS. HENRY: THANK YOU.

SENATOR GIESE: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q YOU'VE BEEN A VERY ACTIVE PERSON IN PROFESSIONAL AND CIVIC ORGANIZATIONS, WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU WOULD BRING TO THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES?
A FIRST OF ALL, THE PRESENT BOARD OF TRUSTEES DOES NOT HAVE ANY FEMALE REPRESENTATION. AND I WOULD BE ABLE TO BRING THAT FEMALE REPRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES. ALSO, I AM PRESENTLY WORKING WITH HIGH SCHOOL AND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL STUDENTS. I WILL BE ABLE TO BRING THAT RESPECT TO THE COLLEGE LEVEL TO INFORM THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND OTHERS WHAT OUR HIGH SCHOOLS ARE DOING AND THAT WOULD HELP US MAKE A BETTER COLLEGE PROGRAM.
Q TELL ME, HOW WOULD YOU GO ABOUT SOLVING THE PROBLEM I HAVE ASKED IN IMPROVING THE QUALITY OF EDUCATION AT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE? I HAVE HAD THREE YOUNG MEN WHO HAVE GONE THROUGH SOUTH CAROLINA STATE WORK WITH ME THE LAST FOUR OR FIVE SUMMERS. THEY WERE REALLY QUALITY STUDENTS, TOP NOTCH, YOU CAN'T FIND ANY BETTER STUDENTS. GENERALLY SPEAKING, WHEN THE LEVEL OF THE INTAKE IS AT THE LEVEL THAT IT IS THE OUTCOME MAY BE SUCH THAT HOW WOULD YOU GO ABOUT RAISING THE QUALITY OF WHAT TAKES PLACE AT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE SO THAT THE GRADUATES ARE COMPETITIVE WHEN THEY GET OUT. AFTER ALL THEY ARE SPENDING FOUR YEARS AND THEY HAVE TO BE COMPETITIVE IN A REAL TOUGH WORLD.
A FIRST OF ALL, IN ORDER TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT YOU HAVE QUALITY PROGRAMS THAT WOULD COMPETE WITH OTHER COLLEGES. SO THAT WHEN OUR STUDENTS FROM SOUTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY GO OUT INTO THE SO-CALLED REAL WORLD THEY ARE ABLE TO COMPETE OTHERS, NOT ONLY FROM SOUTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY BUT ALSO FROM OTHER COLLEGES ACROSS THE NATION. AND IN ORDER TO DO THIS, YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE TO HAVE ADEQUATE FUNDING TO IMPLEMENT THESE PROGRAMS. THAT IS ONE THING THAT WE WOULD HAVE TO GO AFTER, MORE FUNDING FOR BETTER QUALITY PROGRAMS TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF STUDENTS THAT WOULD COME FROM THE INSTITUTION.

SENATOR GIESE: I THINK FUNDING IS BASIC. I DO KNOW THAT THEY ARE DOING IT BECAUSE TWO OR THREE YEARS AGO WE PUT $150,000 PER YEAR INTO BRINGING THEIR BUSINESS SCHOOL INTO A SITUATION WHERE IT COULD BE ACCREDITED THE SAME AS THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA'S AND I THINK THAT IS BASIC. THEY DO HAVE SOME VERY FINE PROGRAMS BUT I THINK THAT IS BASIC TO THE PROBLEM.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

THANK YOU MA'AM.

MS. HENRY: THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: OUR NEXT CANDIDATE IS WILLIE T. SMITH.

(WILLIE T. SMITH, CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR I'M TOLD I'M IN GOOD HEALTH. I JUST FINISHED SURGERY AND THAT'S WHAT MY DOCTORS TOLD ME.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A I THINK SO SIR. EVEN THOUGH I AM A RETIRE JUDGE I WILL HOLD COURT EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE IF NEEDED.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO SIR.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO SIR.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE JUDGE?

SENATOR GIESE: MR. CHAIRMAN.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q JUDGE, WHAT IS YOUR INTEREST, YOU'VE HAD MANY YEARS ON THE BENCH, AND WHAT IS YOUR INTEREST IN SOUTH CAROLINA STATE, BESIDES BEING A GRADUATE?
A SIR, WHEN I DECIDED TO BECOME A LAWYER I WAS PART OF THE SITUATION THAT BEGUN THE LAW SCHOOL AT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE. I WAS EDUCATED AT THAT LAW SCHOOL. I SAW THAT LAW SCHOOL ESTABLISHED IN JUST A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME, OF COURSE, UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE FEDERAL COURT. THAT LAW SCHOOL HAS TURNED OUT SOME OUTSTANDING GRADUATES. AND I SEE NO REASON IN THE WORLD WHY THE PRESENT SCHOOL CAN'T DO THE SAME THING. AND I THINK THAT I CAN PROVIDE THE LEADERSHIP NEEDED TO HELP SOUTH CAROLINA STATE BECOME THAT KIND OF INSTITUTION NOW.
Q JUDGE, DO YOU THINK THE EXPECTATIONS OF THE STUDENTS ARE AT A LEVEL THAT REQUIRES THEM TO REALLY GO ALL OUT TO USE THE MAXIMUM OF THEIR ABILITY?
A SENATOR, THAT IS SOMETHING I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW MORE ABOUT AND I HAVEN'T HAD MUCH CONNECTION WITH THE SCHOOL RECENTLY. AS YOU KNOW, I JUST RETIRED FROM THE BENCH IN JANUARY. BUT I'VE ALWAYS HAD A SINCERE INTEREST IN THE CONTINUING EDUCATION THERE AS A MEMBER OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE LARGEST SCHOOL DISTRICT IN THE SOUTHEAST. AND I THINK WE HAVE TO MOTIVATE CHILDREN. I LOOK AT A BOARD OF TRUSTEES AS A POLICY MAKING BODY. YOU MAKE A POLICY AND THEN YOU SELECT THE STAFF AND PEOPLE WHO ARE GOING TO CARRY OUT THE POLICY. I THINK THAT IS THE KEY TO WHOLE SITUATION. PEOPLE WHO WILL PUT PROGRAMS INTO EFFECT THAT WILL MOTIVATE THE CHILDREN THAT COME THERE THAT WANT AN EDUCATION. AND I THINK THAT IF THEY ARE MOTIVATE, WELL-EDUCATED, AND WELL-TRAINED THEY'LL HELP THE ONES COMING UP BEHIND THEM. I THINK THE BOARD HAS THAT RESPONSIBILITY OF SETTING POLICIES AND FINDING PEOPLE TO CARRY OUT THOSE POLICIES.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? THANK YOU JUDGE.

I APOLOGIZE FOR SKIPPING OVER LEROY MOSELY, JR.

(LEROY MOSELY, JR., CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR I DO NOT.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO SIR.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO SIR.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF MR. MOSELY?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR GIESE.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:

Q MR. MOSELY, ONE OF THE MOST DISCONCERTING STATISTICS ABOUT THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA HIGHER EDUCATION IS THE FACT THAT OVER THIRTY PERCENT OF OUR FRESHMAN HAVE TO TAKE REMEDIAL COURSES. NOW THAT'S NOT JUST SPECIFICALLY SOUTH CAROLINA STATE THAT'S ACROSS THE ENTIRE SYSTEM. I JUST WONDER WHAT OUR HIGH SCHOOLS ARE DOING IF THIRTY PERCENT OF THE STUDENTS HAVE TO RETAKE HIGH SCHOOL WORK IN ORDER TO GET STARTED IN COLLEGE. WHAT WOULD YOU DO ABOUT THAT?
A WELL CERTAINLY HIGHER EDUCATION HAS A RESPONSIBILITY TO ACCEPT THAT AS WE FIND IT, WHILE PERHAPS, TRYING TO ASSIST THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS WOULD BE A BETTER WAY. HOWEVER THOSE STUDENTS WHO HAVE GRADUATED FROM THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND NEED REMEDIATION, WE CANNOT JUST CUT THEM LOOSE AND SAY THAT HIGHER ED IS NOT FOR THEM. THAT EMPHASIZES WHAT I SEE NEED TO HAVE A BETTER REMEDIATION OR A DEVELOPMENTAL PROGRAM IN HIGHER EDUCATION.
Q LET ME GIVE YOU ANOTHER POSSIBLE SCENARIO OR SOLUTION AND TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT THAT. THE STATE PAYS $6000 TO HAVE A STUDENT COME TO THE UNIVERSITY, WE HAVE REMEDIAL PROGRAMS. IT COSTS ABOUT $5600 FOR A STUDENT TO GO CLEMSON, THEY HAVE REMEDIAL PROGRAMS. IT COSTS ABOUT $4200 FOR A STUDENT TO GO TO SOUTH CAROLINA STATE, YOU HAVE REMEDIAL PROGRAMS. WHAT WOULD YOU THINK OF SETTING A STANDARD OF ENTRANCE SUCH THAT IF YOU WANT TO GO TO LET'S SAY A TECH SCHOOL, WE HAVE THOSE ALL OVER THE STATE RIGHT NOW, THAT YOU WOULD EARN YOUR WAY INTO A FOUR YEAR INSTITUTION BY DOING A YEAR AT A TECHNICAL OR ONE OF OUR TWO YEAR COLLEGES WHERE IT COSTS US $2100 PER STUDENT, SO THAT WE DON'T HAVE REMEDIATION GOING ON AT THE FLAGSHIP INSTITUTIONS, ONE OF WHICH WOULD BE YOURS?
A I THINK SOME REMEDIAL COURSES ARE NECESSARY. I WOULD NOT ADVOCATE THAT FOUR YEAR COLLEGES BECOME OVERRUN IF YOU WILL WITH PERSONS IN REMEDIATION. HOWEVER, I AM NOT IN FAVOR OF CLOSING THE DOOR TO ALL PERSONS WHO MAY IN MANY INSTANCES NO FAULT OF THEIR OWN NEED SOME REMEDIATION. I THINK SOME AMOUNT OF THAT IS NEEDED IN THE INSTITUTIONS. I WOULD SUGGEST, HOWEVER, THAT REMEDIATION OUGHT TO BE PERHAPS MORE THE RESPONSIBILTIES OF THE TECHNICAL COLLEGES THAN THE INSTITUTIONS. BUT NONE THE LESS, I THINK THEY ALL SHOULD HAVE SOME AND THEIR LEVELS OF STANDARDS SHOULD BE SUCH THAT IT WOULD NOT PUT SOME SITUATIONS THAT ARE TOTALLY UNMANAGEABLE. BUT NONE THE LESS, SOME AMOUNT OF REMEDIATION IS NECESSARY AT A COLLEGE OR INSTITUTION LIKE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY, ONE THAT HAS A HISTORY AND HERITAGE OF REACHING OUT TO THOSE PERSONS WHO MAY BE MORE DISADVANTAGED EDUCATIONALLY.
Q I WAS KIND OF HOPING THAT YOU MIGHT TAKE OFF ON PERHAPS WE NEED TO RAISE THE STANDARDS THAT WE HAVE IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS SO THAT WE DON'T END UP IN COLLEGES WITH REMEDIATION.
A CERTAINLY, I THINK THAT IS NEEDED BUT AT THIS POINT IN TIME WE HAVE THE SITUATION AND WE MUST DEAL WITH IT. THOSE STUDENTS WHO HAVE ALREADY GRADUATED AND ARE COMING TO US NOW OR EVEN THOSE WHO MAY BE COMING IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF YEARS, IT MAY BE TO LATE. SO I WOULD SAY THAT WE NOT CLOSE OUR DOORS AND OBVIOUSLY OVER TIME I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS PUT OUT BETTER STUDENTS SO THAT THE AMOUNT OF REMEDIATION THAT WE NOW HAVE TO DO IS NOT NECESSARY. I THINK WHEN I RESPONDED TO YOUR QUESTION I WAS THINKING MORE IN TERMS OF WHAT WE HAVE TODAY.

SENATOR GIESE: I HOPE THAT THE BOARDS WOULD BE CATALYSTS TO THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND TO THE HIGHER EDUCATION SO THAT THE BOARDS WOULD LET THE PEOPLE KNOW THAT WE NEED TO HAVE HIGHER QUALITY STUDENTS COMING OUT OF OUR HIGH SCHOOLS WHICH MEANS THAT WE SHOULD BE SPENDING TWELVE YEARS THAT WE KEEP THESE KIDS IN SCHOOL AND BRING THEM TO A LEVEL SO THAT WE DON'T HAVE TO REPAY FOR THEIR EDUCATION THROUGH TAKING THE HIGH SCHOOL COURSES OVER AGAIN AT A COLLEGE LEVEL. BUT THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: ONE QUESTION?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. MARTIN.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN:

Q I SEE WHERE YOU ATTENDED SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE, IT DOESN'T SAY WHETHER OR NOT YOU RECEIVED A DEGREE FROM THERE OR NOT?
A YES SIR I DID. BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION AND ACCOUNTING IN 1969.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS GENTLEMEN?

YOU MAY STEP DOWN MR. MOSELY. WE CERTAINLY APPRECIATE ALL OF YOU COMING. THAT COVERS EVERYONE WE HAVE PRESENT THIS MORNING.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. CLYBORNE.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: I MAKE A MOTION THAT THOSE THAT APPEAR BE CERTIFIED.

SENATOR GIESE: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MOTION MADE AND SECONDED THAT ALL THE CANDIDATES THAT HAVE APPEARED BE CERTIFIED AS QUALIFIED. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT. WE CERTAINLY APPRECIATE YOUR DESIRE TO SERVE AND APPRECIATE YOU COMING THIS MORNING.

THE MOTION HAS BEEN MADE THAT THE COMMITTEE ADJOURN. THE AYES HAVE IT.

BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES

FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF

STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES

COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDING

SCREENING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, HELD IN ROOM 433, BLATT STATE OFFICE BUILDING, COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA, ON APRIL 30, 1992, COMMENCING AT THE HOUR OF 9:00 A.M.

MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE IN ATTENDANCE:
REPRESENTATIVE EUGENE C. STODDARD, CHAIRMAN
SENATOR ALEXANDER MACAULAY, VICE-CHAIRMAN
REPRESENTATIVE DANIEL E. MARTIN, SR., SECRETARY
SENATOR JOE WILSON
REPRESENTATIVE H. HOWELL CLYBORNE, JR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: WELL, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN IT'S NICE TO HAVE YOU WITH US AND WE'LL START NOW.

(ROBERT BEDENBAUGH, CANDIDATE FOR THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR WIL LOU GRAY OPPORTUNITY SCHOOL, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO SIR.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO SIR.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q COULD YOU TELL US BRIEFLY WHY YOU'D LIKE TO SERVE ON THIS BOARD?
A I HAVE A LOT OF EXPERIENCE. I HAVE WORKED IN PERSONNEL, IN ADMINISTRATION, I'VE BEEN A PRINCIPAL, I'VE BEEN A TEACHER. I NOW WORK IN THE SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, SO I HAVE STATEWIDE INTEREST IN EDUCATION. I BELIEVE IN ALTERNATIVE PROGRAMS. I WRITE A DISSERTATION A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO DEALING WITH ALTERNATIVE PROGRAMS. IT IS REAL INTEREST OF MINE MR. STODDARD

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

SENATOR.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR MACAULAY:

Q DR. BEDENBAUGH, YOU PUT DOWN DIRECTOR OF SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION. WHAT IS YOUR DEPARTMENT OR DIVISION?
A I DIRECT THE OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT. WE'RE ABOUT ASSESSING AND DEVELOPING POTENTIAL SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS AND WE DO SOME TEACHER TRAINING ALSO.
Q IN THAT CAPACITY, WOULD YOU IN ANY WAY HAVE ANY SORT OF ASSOCIATION WITH WIL LOU GRAY FACULTY OR STAFF?
A NONE.

SENATOR MACAULAY: THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

THANK YOU MR. BEDENBAUGH.

MR. BEDENBAUGH: THANK YOU SIR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: OUR NEXT CANDIDATE IS ELIZABETH MOORHEAD.

(ELIZABETH MOORHEAD, CANDIDATE FOR THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR WIL LOU GRAY OPPORTUNITY SCHOOL, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO, SIR.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES, SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE LADY?

SENATOR WILSON: MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR WILSON.

SENATOR WILSON: DO WE HAVE THE PERSONAL DATA AND QUESTIONNAIRE?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: NO, I DON'T HAVE COPIES BUT WE'LL HAND AROUND THE ONE WE HAVE.

SENATOR WILSON: THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: I MIGHT GO AHEAD AND ASK YOU THE SAME QUESTION I ASKED THE GENTLEMAN BEFORE.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q COULD YOU TELL US BRIEFLY WHY YOU'D LIKE TO SERVE ON THIS BOARD?
A I'VE BEEN IN EDUCATION FOR TWENTY YEARS. I WAS TEACHER FOR ALL OF THOSE YEARS EXCEPT THIS PRESENT YEAR FOR WHICH NOW I AM THE COORDINATOR OF THE CHAPTER ONE PROGRAM IN CHEROKEE COUNTY. AT-RISK STUDENTS HAVE ALWAYS BEEN AN EXTREME INTEREST OF MINE, WHICH IS THE REASON I WANTED TO GET INTO THE PROGRAM THAT I AM IN RIGHT NOW. WE TRY INNOVATED NEW WAYS, ANY WAY THAT WE CAN FIND, TO WORK WITH THESE PARTICULAR CHILDREN. I AM A THIS POINT IN MY LIFE WHERE YOU NO LONGER HAVE TO BE AT HOME BECAUSE MY CHILDREN ARE AWAY.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

SENATOR WILSON.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR WILSON:

Q MR. CHAIRMAN, I REPRESENT THE COMMUNITY WHERE WIL LOU GRAY IS LOCATED AND SO I AM VERY INTERESTED IN THE SCHOOL. DO YOU HAVE ANY DIRECT RELATIONSHIP TO THE SCHOOL NOW?
A NO SIR.
Q BUT YOU'VE REFERRED STUDENTS TO IT I'M SURE?
A NO. THIS IS THE FIRST YEAR THAT I'VE BEEN WITH CHAPTER ONE.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

THANK YOU MA'AM.

REPRESENTATIVE CLYBORNE: I MOVE THAT WE CERTIFY THEM, MR. CHAIRMAN.

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: MR. CLYBORNE MOVES THAT YOU BE CERTIFIED, SECONDED BY MR. MARTIN. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT.

WE APPRECIATE Y'ALL COMING AND WE FIND YOU QUALIFIED.

NEXT WE HAVE TWO CANDIDATES FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE BOARD. I BELIEVE THEY ARE BOTH INCUMBENTS. THEY BOTH HAD CONFLICTS LAST WEEK WHEN WE SCREENED THAT GROUP. FIRST, WE'LL HAVE HENRY W. BREVARD.

(HENRY W. BREVARD, CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES I WOULD.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO SIR.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO I DO NOT.
Q ANY QUESTIONS OF THE GENTLEMAN?

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR WILSON.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR WILSON:

Q MR. CHAIRMAN, I NOTICED IN TODAY'S NEWSPAPER AND SAW ON TELEVISION LAST NIGHT, CONCERN ABOUT SOUTH CAROLINA STATE NOW UNIVERSITY FUNDS FOR ITS INDEPENDENT FOUNDATION. AND WHAT IS YOUR POSITION ON UPDATING OF THE RECORDS AND ALSO IN TERMS OF DISCLOSURE?
A I THINK THAT WE NEED TO TAKE A VERY CLOSE LOOK AT THE FOUNDATION. I THINK AT OUR MEETING ON THE SIXTH OF MAY THE SUBJECT WILL COME UP AND WE WILL BE TALKING WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE FOUNDATION AND THE CURRENT DIRECTOR OF THE FOUNDATION TO GATHER SOME INFORMATION.L IF I AM STILL THERE I PLAN TO APPOINT A COMMITTEE TO LOOK INTO THIS ALONG WITH A COMMITTEE FROM THE FOUNDATION TO DETERMINE WHETHER WE ARE DOING ALL OF THE THINGS THAT WE NEED TO DO OR WHETHER WE NEED TO GO OUT AND GET SOME OUTSIDE HELP TO HELP US TO BRIDGE THE GAP BETWEEN DISSEMINATING INFORMATION THAT WE SHOULD OR THAT WE NEED TO MAKE CERTAIN THAT OUR RECORDS, OUR LAST AUDIT, THAT WE GOT WAS A CLEAN AUDIT FOR THE FOUNDATION. SO EVIDENTLY, WE NEED TO LOOK AT SOME OTHER THINGS THAT THE FOUNDATION IS DOING AND I'M SURE THAT THE BOARD WILL TAKE THIS UP.
Q I PERSONALLY BELIEVE THAT THE FOUNDATION FUNDS ARE SOMETIMES A MIXTURE OF PUBLIC AND PRIVATE FUNDS THEREFORE I BELIEVE THEY SHOULD BE OPEN TO THE PUBLIC FOR REVIEW. WHAT IS YOUR POSITION ON THAT?
A I THINK THAT WE COME UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT. I HAVE NOT HAD ANYONE TO CHECK ALL OF THE LEGALITIES OF IT, BUT I PLAN TO. AND IF THIS IS TRUE THEN WE CERTAINLY WILL SEE TO IT THAT THE INFORMATION THAT SHOULD BE MADE PUBLIC WILL BE MADE PUBLIC. I DON'T THINK THAT THERE IS ANYTHING TO HIDE AT THE FOUNDATION. I AM SORRY THAT THE CONTROVERSY CAME UP. IT CAME AT A VERY BAD TIME FOR US BUT I'M SURE THAT IF THERE IS SOMETHING THAT IT WILL BE DISCLOSED.

SENATOR WILSON: THANK YOU.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS GENTLEMEN?

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: YES SIR. I'D LIKE TO ASK SOMETHING.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN:

Q DR. BREVARD, THERE IS A BILL IN THE LEGISLATURE NOW, ONE IN THE HOUSE AND ONE IN THE SENATE, THAT BASICALLY SOMEWHAT RESTRUCTURES THE BOARD MEMBER'S PARTICIPATION, THAT IS BY CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICTS AND INCREASING THE NUMBER OF MEMBERS ON THE BOARD. IF YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH THE BILL, DO YOU HAVE ANY FEELINGS AS TO WHETHER OR NOT IT WOULD SERVE AS A POSITIVE AS OPPOSED TO A NEGATIVE, NOT THAT THE COLLEGE IS A UNIVERSITY?

WELL, I THINK THAT HAVING READ THE BILL ITSELF, I THINK THAT IT'S A GOOD BILL. I THINK THAT THE NUMBERS WOULD ALLOW US TO HAVE A BROADER-BASED GROUP OF INDIVIDUALS THAT REPRESENT ALL FACETS OF SOUTH CAROLINA AND I SHOULD HAVE SAID ALL GEOGRAPHIC REGIONS OF SOUTH CAROLINA BY DOING BY DISTRICTS. AND I THINK THAT IT WILL HELP THE BOARD IN THAT ASPECT. I CERTAINLY DON'T FEEL THAT IT WILL HARM THE BOARD IN ANY WAY. I THINK THAT IT WILL ENHANCE THE SHARING OF IDEAS. WHEN YOU HAVE A LARGE GROUP OF PEOPLE THE PROBLEMS THAT YOU RUN INTO IS THAT DECISION-MAKING BECOMES A LITTLE MORE DIFFICULT. I'M SURE THAT EACH OF YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH THAT. HOWEVER, GROUP DECISIONS ARE BETTER DECISIONS, IT'S JUST THAT THEY ARE MORE EXPENSIVE AND MORE TIME CONSUMING THAN ANYTHING ELSE. BUT I THINK THAT THERE ARE SOME POSITIVES THAT CAN COME OUT OF IT.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS GENTLEMEN?

SENATOR WILSON: ONE FINAL COMMENT. I NOTICED HERE, I REMEMBER VERY WELL, WHEN YOU CAME THROUGH THE FIRST TIME, I BELIEVE IN 1986. I REMEMBER YOU BEING GIVEN INFORMATION ABOUT DUAL OFFICE HOLDING AND WHERE YOU WERE CONFRONTED WITH A DILEMMA OF CONTINUED SERVICE ON THE TOWN COUNCIL IN MONCKS CORNER OR SERVICE OF THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE BOARD AND I HAVE ALWAYS BEEN IMPRESSED THAT YOU DID NOT HESITATE TWO SECONDS TO SAY THAT YOU WANTED TO SERVE ON THE BOARD. I'VE BEEN IMPRESSED WITH YOUR SERVICE AND AGAIN WANTED TO BRING THAT TO THE ATTENTION FOR A NEWCOMER AT LEAST BECAUSE I HAVE NEVER SEEN THAT BEFORE WHERE SOMEONE WAS CONFRONTED BUT YET MADE HIS DECISION VERY QUICKLY.

MR. BREVARD: THANK YOU SIR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: I REMEMBER THE OCCASION. THANK YOU SIR.

OUR NEXT CANDIDATE IS CHARLES H. WILLIAMS.

(CHARLES H. WILLIAMS, CANDIDATE FOR THE SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, WAS DULY SWORN IN BY THE CHAIRMAN.)

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q DO YOU HAVE ANY HEALTH-RELATED PROBLEMS THAT THE SCREENING COMMITTEE SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THAT WOULD PREVENT YOU FROM SERVING ON THE BOARD IN A FULL CAPACITY?
A NO SIR.
Q CONSIDERING YOUR PRESENT OCCUPATION AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS ON A REGULAR BASIS?
A YES SIR.
Q DO YOU HAVE ANY INTERESTS, PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY, THAT PRESENT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST BECAUSE OF YOUR SERVICE ON THE BOARD?
A NO SIR.
Q DO YOU NOW HOLD ANY PUBLIC POSITION OF HONOR OR TRUST THAT, IF ELECTED TO THE BOARD, WOULD CAUSE YOU TO VIOLATE THE DUAL OFFICE HOLDING CLAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTION?
A NO SIR.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD:

Q COULD YOU TELL US BRIEFLY WHY YOU'D LIKE TO CONTINUE TO SERVE ON THIS BOARD, MR. WILLIAMS?
A YES, SIR. GENTLEMAN, OF COURSE, I'VE BEEN ON THIS BOARD FOR SIX YEARS. I'M A LIFELONG RESIDENT OF ORANGEBURG AND HAVE GROWN UP AROUND STATE COLLEGE. WHEN I GOT ON THE BOARD IT THOUGHT IT WAS IMPORTANT THAT THE COMMUNITY BECOME INVOLVED IN SOUTH CAROLINA STATE COLLEGE. EVERYONE HERE KNOWS IT IS A HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGE. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT THE BOARD HAVE WHITE TRUSTEES WHO SUPPORT THE COLLEGE. I THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT NOT ONLY TO THE WHITE COMMUNITY BUT TO THE BLACK COMMUNITY. I THINK THAT STATE COLLEGE HAS BECOME A LOT MORE INVOLVED IN OUR COMMUNITY AND OUR COMMUNITY HAS BECOME INVOLVED IN STATE COLLEGE. I THINK THAT AT THIS POINT IN TIME WHEN I CAME ON THE BOARD THEY WERE IN THE PROCESS OF PICKING A NEW PRESIDENT. I THINK THAT ANY INSTITUTION IT IS TERRIBLY IMPORTANT WHAT KIND OF PRESIDENT YOU HAVE RUNNING THE INSTITUTION. I AM ON THAT SEARCH COMMITTEE. THE ABILITY TO TRY AND FIND SOMEONE THAT WOULD BE AN ASSET NOT ONLY TO STATE COLLEGE BUT TO THE STATE, GOES WITHOUT SAYING THAT COLLEGES AND OUR EDUCATION SYSTEM MAKES UP THE FUTURE OF THIS STATE. I ENJOY BEING ON IT AND ENJOY THE DIFFERENT BOARD MEMBERS AND PEOPLE AT THE SCHOOL THAT I WORK WITH.
Q ARE YOU THE ONLY RESIDENT OF ORANGEBURG ON THIS BOARD?
A NO SIR. THERE ARE THREE ON THERE. THERE HAVE BEEN TWO ELECTED SINCE I WAS ELECTED. AT ONE TIME I WAS THE ONLY ONE.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

SENATOR WILSON: MR. CHAIRMAN.

EXAMINATION BY SENATOR WILSON:

Q YOU'VE HEARD MY CONCERNS ABOUT THE FOUNDATION AND THE PAST RECORDKEEPING AND ALSO AS TO WHETHER IT'S OPEN TO THE PUBLIC NOW AND IN THE FUTURE. WHAT'S YOUR POSITION ON THE FOUNDATION?
A MINE IS THAT IT WOULD BE OPEN. I WAS UNDER THE IMPRESSION THAT THEY HAD ALREADY COME OUT AND MADE THE LAW THAT SAID THE BOOKS WERE OPEN. I JUST HEARD THERE WAS A STATEMENT MADE BY THE FOUNDATIONS PRESIDENT THAT WAS INCORRECT AND I WAS ASSURED THAT ALL FOUNDATION RECORDS WOULD BE OPEN TO THE PUBLIC FOR INSPECTION. AND I CERTAINLY THINK THEY SHOULD BE.
Q AND THEY'LL BE AUDITED AND MAINTAINED IN AUDITABLE CONDITION IN THE FUTURE?
A THAT'S THE WAY I WOULD CERTAINLY RECOMMEND IT. YES SIR.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?

MR. MARTIN.

EXAMINATION BY REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN:

Q I WAS GOING TO ASK MR. WILLIAMS BASICALLY THE SAME QUESTION I ASKED DR. BREVARD CONCERNING THE BILL?
A MR. MARTIN, I'M FOR THE BILL. AND MY REASONS ARE MAYBE A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT THAN MR. BREVARD'S. I THINK IT IS A MISTAKE, AND OF COURSE, I MIGHT BE PART OF THAT MISTAKE. I DON'T THINK YOU NEED THREE PEOPLE FROM ORANGEBURG ON A BOARD. THEY'RE IN THAT TOWN, YOU JUST DON'T THINK IT'S GOOD FOR A UNIVERSITY TO HAVE THAT MANY, THREE OUT OF NINE, A THIRD OF ITS BOARD, IN THE TOWN IN WHICH IT COMES FROM. I'M ALSO CONCERNED WITH BASICALLY FOUR OR MAYBE FIVE, BECAUSE WE DON'T ALWAYS HAVE A FULL BOARD, BEING ABLE TO MAKE DECISIONS FOR THAT COLLEGE. I THINK THE NEW BILL PROPOSES THIRTEEN AND I DON'T KNOW IF YOU SHOULD EVER HAVE AN INSTITUTION AS LARGE AS SOUTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY WHERE FOUR OR FIVE PEOPLE CAN MAKE A DECISION. AND IT GOES WITHOUT SAYING, Y'ALL KNOW WE'VE HAD SOME PRETTY SPLIT VOTES HERE RECENTLY. AND I JUST THINK BY EXPANDING, BY MAKING STATE-WIDE IN GEOGRAPHICS WILL BE THE BENEFIT OF THAT COLLEGE. IT MIGHT COST ME MY SEAT BUT I JUST THINK IT'S BETTER NOT TO HAVE SO MANY PEOPLE FROM ORANGEBURG ON A UNIVERSITY THAT'S SO IMPORTANT TO THIS STATE.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS?

THANK YOU SIR.

SENATOR WILSON: I MOVE THAT THE CANDIDATES ARE QUALIFIED.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SENATOR WILSON MOVES THAT THE CANDIDATES BE FOUND QUALIFIED.

REPRESENTATIVE MARTIN: I SECOND.

REPRESENTATIVE STODDARD: SECONDED MY MR. MARTIN. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT.

WE FIND YOU BOTH QUALIFIED. THANK YOU FOR COMING THIS MORNING.

THE MOTION HAS BEEN MADE THAT THE COMMITTEE ADJOURN. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE, OPPOSED NO. THE AYES HAVE IT.

PURSUANT TO ACT 119 OF 1975, THE COMMITTEE TO SCREEN CANDIDATES FOR BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF STATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES WAS CONVENED TO CONSIDER THE QUALIFICATIONS OF CANDIDATES SEEKING TO FILL CERTAIN POSITIONS ON BOARDS OF TRUSTEES OF THE STATE'S COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES. THE COMMITTEE CONDUCTS SUCH INVESTIGATION OF EACH CANDIDATE AS IT DEEMS APPROPRIATE AND REPORTS ITS FINDINGS TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PRIOR TO ELECTION. IT IS NOT THE FUNCTION OF THE COMMITTEE TO RECOMMEND ONE CANDIDATE OVER ANOTHER OR TO SUGGEST TO THE INDIVIDUAL LEGISLATOR FOR WHOM TO VOTE. OUR ROLE IS INSTEAD THAT OF DETERMINING WHETHER A CANDIDATE IS QUALIFIED AND UNDER THE STATUTE OUR DETERMINATION IN THAT REGARD IS NOT BINDING UPON THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

THE CANDIDATES WHO WERE UNDER CONSIDERATION AT THE TIME OF THESE HEARINGS ARE DISCUSSED IN THIS REPORT.

THE CANDIDATES ARE:

LANDER COLLEGE

First District
Nancy J. Cash
Second District
George R. Starnes
Third District
Timothy D. Etson
Jean T. McFerrin
Fourth District
C. Tyrone Gilmore
Fifth District
S. Anne Walker
Sixth District
Walter D. Smith
At-Large
Mary D. Moore
William Stevens
CITADEL--One seat

David S. Boyd
W.E. Jenkinson, III

COLLEGE OF CHARLESTON

First District
Cheryl D. Whipper
Second District
Joel H. Smith
Third District
William J. Day
Fourth District
Merl F. Code
Fifth District
John V. Price
Sixth District
Marie M. Land
At-Large
Timothy N. Dangerfield

MEDICAL UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA

Lay Trustees
First District-- Melvyn Berlinsky
Second District--Patricia T. Smith
Third District--Milford J. Cooper

Jack F. McIntosh

Medical Profession
Fourth District--Dr. Charles B. Hanna
Fifth District--Dr. Cotesworth P. Fishburne
Sixth District--Dr. E. Conyers O'Bryan

WIL LOU GRAY OPPORTNITY SCHOOL - Three seats

Wilhelmina McBride
Dr. Marvin Efron
Olive F. Wilson

FRANCIS MARION

First District
J. Michael Murphree
Second District
Lorraine H. Knight
Third District
William A. Collins
Lee Miller
Fourth District
SEAT 7 - H. Randall Dozier
SEAT 8 - Robert E. Lanford, Jr.
Fifth District
Tracy L. Eggleston
Sixth District
William W. Coleman, Jr.
At-Large
M. Russell Holliday, Jr.

SOUTH CAROLINA STATE - Two seats

Henry W. Brevard
George S. Chenault
Willis H. Crosby
Sam Glover
Janette Henry
Leroy Mosely, Jr.
Willie T. Smith
Charles H. Williams

WINTHROP - Two seats

Robert Gahagan
Sanita L. Savage

WIL LOU GRAY OPPORTUNITY SCHOOL - Two seats
Russell S. Bedenbaugh
Elizabeth Moorhead

(On motion of Senator NELL W. SMITH, ordered printed in the Journal)

ADJOURNMENT

At 11:15 A.M., on motion of Senator SHEALY, the Senate adjourned to meet next Tuesday, May 12, 1992, at 12:00 Noon.

* * *


This web page was last updated on Tuesday, June 30, 2009 at 8:55 A.M.