Amendment

motion to divide the question in violation of Rule 8.10; sustained

Printed Page 1363, Mar. 18

out of order as not germane;

sustained

Printed Page 1096, Mar. 10
Printed Page 1803, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1805, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1909, Apr. 8
Printed Page 2293, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2964, May 6
Printed Page 3690, May 20
Printed Page 3884, May 25
Printed Page 4136, May 27
Printed Page 4149, May 27
Printed Page 4434, June 2
Printed Page 4496, June 2
Printed Page 4500, June 2
Printed Page 4502, June 2

overruled

Printed Page 600, Feb. 3
Printed Page 1078, Mar. 10
Printed Page 1091, Mar. 10
Printed Page 1097, Mar. 10
Printed Page 1100, Mar. 10
Printed Page 1756, Apr. 6
Printed Page 1790, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1799, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1849, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1948, Apr. 13
Printed Page 2499, Apr. 29
Printed Page 2950, May 6
Printed Page 2966, May 6
Printed Page 2970, May 6
Printed Page 3603, May 19
Printed Page 4104, May 27
Printed Page 4160, May 27
Printed Page 4287, June 1
Printed Page 4497, June 2

out of order as not germane in that the amendment dealt with a statewide matter and the Joint Resolution dealt with a local matter; sustained

Printed Page 1952, Apr. 13

out of order as not germane in that the amendment dealt with bingo equipment and the Bill dealt with the hours of operation of bingo games for senior citizens; overruled

Printed Page 1945, Apr. 13

out of order as not germane in that the amendment dealt with electronic equipment and the Bill dealt with the regulation of the operation of the game of bingo; sustained

Printed Page 1892, Apr. 8

out of order in that the amendment dealt with local property taxes and the bill dealt with state government taxes; overruled

Printed Page 3970, May 26

out of order as not germane in that the amendment dealt with prohibiting all forms of gambling and the Joint Resolution dealt with authorizing the lottery; sustained

Printed Page 1747, Apr. 6

out of order as not germane in that the amendment dealt with seat belts and the Bill dealt with speed limits; overruled

Printed Page 1053, Mar. 9

out of order as not germane in that the amendment dealt with the school's policy on sexual assault and the amendment dealt with the school's housing policy; overruled

Printed Page 4010, May 26

out of order as not germane in that the amendment further directs how the revenue is to be collected and spent and the Joint Resolution authorizes a lottery; overruled

Printed Page 1782, Apr. 7

out of order in that it dealt with House Rules and not the Constitution of South Carolina and was not germane to the Bill; overruled

Printed Page 463, Jan. 26

out of order in that it was in violation of Article XVI, Section 2 of the Constitution of the State of SC, which requires that two or more amendments submitted at the same time should be submitted separately to the voters of SC; overruled

Printed Page 1782, Apr. 7

out of order in that it was identical to a previously tabled amendment; sustained

Printed Page 4004, May 26

out of order under Rule 4.4 and 5.1 in that the Bill as amended directly appropriated money and should therefore be referred to the Ways and Means Committee before it shall be considered by the House; overruled

Printed Page 4010, May 26

out of order under Rule 8.3 in that the amendments were dilatory in nature and should not be entertained by the Speaker; overruled

Printed Page 4007, May 26

out of order in that under Rule 5.13 a fiscal impact statement was required to be attached to the Joint Resolution; overruled

Printed Page 4379, June 2

out of order in that under Rule 9.3 the amendment rewrites the Bill in its entirety and therefore is not germane to the original title of the bill; sustained

Printed Page 5061, June 30

Printed Page 5139, June 30

out of order in that the amendment attempted to amend a local bill which changed it to a statewide bill; sustained

Printed Page 4557, June 3

out of order in that it did not relate to the fiscal year provided for in the Bill; overruled

Printed Page 2813, May 5

Amendment to Appropriations Bill

motion to divide the question out of order in that it was in violation of Rule 8.10; sustained

Printed Page 1363, Mar. 18

motions affecting bills on third reading are not in order until the particular bill is reached on the calendar in accordance with Section 712 of Mason's Manual; overruled

Printed Page 1531, Mar. 23

out of order as not germane;

sustained

Printed Page 1182, Mar. 15
Printed Page 1243, Mar. 16
Printed Page 1401, Mar. 18

overruled

Printed Page 1183, Mar. 15
Printed Page 1196, Mar. 15
Printed Page 1224, Mar. 16
Printed Page 1244, Mar. 16
Printed Page 1367, Mar. 18

out of order in that it was not germane to the Bill in that it did not relate to a line item in Part IA of the Appropriations Bill;

overruled

Printed Page 2692, May 5

sustained

Printed Page 2717, May 5

out of order in that it was identical to a previous amendment which had been ruled out of order; sustained

Printed Page 1212, Mar. 16

out of order in that it was in violation of a 1995 precedent, the State Constitution and Rule 5.4; sustained

Printed Page 1254, Mar. 16

out of order in that it was in violation of Article X, Section 1 of the State Constitution; overruled

Printed Page 1272, Mar. 17

out of order in that it was in violation of Code Section

11-11-140; overruled

Printed Page 1190, Mar. 15

sustained

Printed Page 1391, Mar. 18

out of order in that it was in violation of the Equal Protection Clause; overruled

Printed Page 1393, Mar. 18

out of order under Rule 5.3B;

sustained

Printed Page 1229, Mar. 16
Printed Page 1245, Mar. 16
Printed Page 1321, Mar. 17
Printed Page 1322, Mar. 17
Printed Page 1399, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1425, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1440, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1452, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1456, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1470, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1471, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1479, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1497, Mar. 18

overruled

Printed Page 1191, Mar. 15
Printed Page 1243, Mar. 16
Printed Page 1323, Mar. 17
Printed Page 1357, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1387, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1393, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1397, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1407, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1430, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1449, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1453, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1468, Mar. 18
Printed Page 1489, Mar. 18

out of order under Rule 5.3B and similar to a 1994 precedent; overruled

Printed Page 1481, Mar. 18

section out of order under Rule 5.3A; overruled

Printed Page 1190, Mar. 15

section out of order under Rule 5.3; overruled

Printed Page 1224, Mar. 16
Printed Page 1384, Mar. 18

sections out of order in that they did not relate to the fiscal year provided for in the Bill; sustained

Printed Page 2813, May 5

Bill

out of order as improperly before the House for consideration since its number and title had not been printed in the Calendar at least one statewide legislative day prior to second reading; sustained

Printed Page 426, Jan. 21
Printed Page 533, Jan. 28
Printed Page 536, Jan. 28
Printed Page 537, Jan. 28
Printed Page 667, Feb. 9
Printed Page 668, Feb. 9
Printed Page 690, Feb. 10
Printed Page 740, Feb. 16
Printed Page 773, Feb. 17
Printed Page 774, Feb. 17
Printed Page 809, Feb. 18
Printed Page 810, Feb. 18
Printed Page 811, Feb. 18
Printed Page 812, Feb. 18
Printed Page 813, Feb. 18
Printed Page 904, Feb. 25
Printed Page 973, Mar. 3
Printed Page 999, Mar. 4
Printed Page 1043, Mar. 9
Printed Page 1083, Mar. 10
Printed Page 1128, Mar. 11
Printed Page 1130, Mar. 11
Printed Page 1157, Mar. 15
Printed Page 1645, Mar. 30
Printed Page 1646, Mar. 30
Printed Page 1648, Mar. 30
Printed Page 1677, Mar. 31
Printed Page 1679, Mar. 31
Printed Page 1721, Apr. 6
Printed Page 1722, Apr. 6
Printed Page 1723, Apr. 6
Printed Page 1725, Apr. 6
Printed Page 1778, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1780, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1973, Apr. 14
Printed Page 2011, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2012, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2013, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2014, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2015, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2016, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2207, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2208, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2209, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2210, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2211, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2214, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2215, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2220, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2223, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2266, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2318, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2325, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2327, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2339, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2340, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2347, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2349, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2502, Apr. 29
Printed Page 2503, Apr. 29
Printed Page 2504, Apr. 29
Printed Page 2630, May 4
Printed Page 2899, May 6
Printed Page 2900, May 6
Printed Page 2901, May 6
Printed Page 2903, May 6
Printed Page 2904, May 6
Printed Page 3041, May 11
Printed Page 3042, May 11
Printed Page 3072, May 12
Printed Page 3074, May 12
Printed Page 3078, May 12
Printed Page 3184, May 13
Printed Page 3187, May 13
Printed Page 3952, May 26
Printed Page 3961, May 26
Printed Page 4062, May 27
Printed Page 4063, May 27
Printed Page 4064, May 27
Printed Page 4067, May 27
Printed Page 4068, May 27
Printed Page 4069, May 27
Printed Page 4075, May 27
Printed Page 4076, May 27
Printed Page 4082, May 27
Printed Page 4182, May 27
Printed Page 4183, May 27
Printed Page 4184, May 27
Printed Page 4185, May 27
Printed Page 4186, May 27
Printed Page 4188, May 27
Printed Page 4309, June 1
Printed Page 4310, June 1
Printed Page 4321, June 1

out of order in that the Bill required a fiscal impact statement

under Code Section 2-7-76; sustained

Printed Page 565, Feb. 2

out of order in that the Bill required a fiscal impact statement

under Rule 5.13; overruled

Printed Page 2150, Apr. 21

Printed Page 3083, May 12
Printed Page 3084, May 12

out of order in that the Bill required an expenditure of funds by the county; overruled

Printed Page 2463, Apr. 28

out of order in that the Bill was in violation of Code Section 2-1-180; sustained

Printed Page 5010, June 30

out of order under Rule 4.4 in that the Bill appropriated money in its attempt to set up grants and therefore should be referred to the Ways and Means Committee; overruled

Printed Page 2437, Apr. 28

should be placed on the statewide uncontested calendar; overruled

Printed Page 1574, Mar. 24

required a two-thirds vote pursuant to Code Section 4-9-55; overruled

Printed Page 1591, Mar. 24

Conference Committee

the same members could not be appointed to more than one committee on the same subject; overruled

Printed Page 5196, June 30

Conference Report

out of order in that it had not been printed in the Journal; sustained

Printed Page 2162, Apr. 21

Joint Resolution

out of order in that it appropriated more than ten million dollars and therefore was required to show a corresponding reduction in appropriation; overruled

Printed Page 401, Jan. 20

out of order in that it did not have an attached fiscal impact statement as required under Rule 5.3; sustained

Printed Page 2628, May 4
Printed Page 3019, May 11

out of order as improperly before the House for consideration since its number and title had not been printed in the Calendar at least one statewide legislative day prior to second reading; sustained

Printed Page 425, Jan. 21
Printed Page 668, Feb. 9
Printed Page 813, Feb. 18
Printed Page 968, Mar. 3
Printed Page 1130, Mar. 11
Printed Page 1131, Mar. 11
Printed Page 1724, Apr. 6
Printed Page 1779, Apr. 7
Printed Page 1780, Apr. 7
Printed Page 2014, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2016, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2017, Apr. 15
Printed Page 2142, Apr. 21
Printed Page 2214, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2505, Apr. 29
Printed Page 2902, May 6
Printed Page 4321, June 1
Printed Page 4322, June 1
Printed Page 4323, June 1
Printed Page 4324, June 1
Printed Page 4325, June 1
Printed Page 4326, June 1
Printed Page 4327, June 1
Printed Page 4328, June 1
Printed Page 4329, June 1

in violation of the provision requiring a single subject in a Joint Resolution as in accordance with Article III, Section 17; overruled

Printed Page 580, Feb. 3

ballot question in Joint Resolution does not fairly and plainly describe the proposed constitutional amendment and violated the Supreme Court's interpretation of Article XVI, Section 1, of the South Carolina Constitution; overruled

Printed Page 644, Feb. 4

Motion

no dilatory motion shall be entertained by the Speaker under Rule 3.9; overruled

Printed Page 2922, May 6

once the question is divided for debate, each question must be disposed of before the motion to recommit can be made; sustained

Printed Page 236, Jan. 14

to adjourn with the stipulation of returning on a certain date was out of order; overruled

Printed Page 5197, June 30

to divide the question was out of order in that it was in violation of Rule 8.10; sustained

Printed Page 1363, Mar. 18

affecting bills on third reading are not in order until the particular bill is reached on the calendar in accordance with Section 712 of Mason's Manual; overruled

Printed Page 1531, Mar. 23

fifteen minutes had not elapsed since a similar motion was made; sustained

Printed Page 2915, May 6

Question

out of order in that it was not germane to the Bill; sustained

Printed Page 1094, Mar. 10

Senate Amendments

out of order as improperly before the House for consideration since its number and title had not been printed in the Calendar at least one statewide legislative day prior to second reading; sustained

Printed Page 1001, Mar. 4
Printed Page 1084, Mar. 10
Printed Page 2269, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2270, Apr. 27
Printed Page 2398, Apr. 28
Printed Page 2399, Apr. 28
Printed Page 2907, May 6
Printed Page 3650, May 19
Printed Page 3651, May 19
Printed Page 3888, May 25
Printed Page 3889, May 25
Printed Page 3894, May 25
Printed Page 3972, May 26
Printed Page 3973, May 26
Printed Page 4297, June 1
Printed Page 4298, June 1
Printed Page 4332, June 1
Printed Page 4559, June 3

Last Updated: Friday, June 26, 2009 at 9:34 A.M.