Amendment

out of order in that the amendment affected fiscal year 2011-2012 and the fiscal years beyond, while the Joint Resolution was a temporary measure dealing only with fiscal years 2008-2009 and 2009-2010; sustained

Printed Page 1187, Feb. 18

out of order under House Rule 9.5 in that amendments should be taken up in the order in which they are received and the amendment was a substitute amendment and was not the same version that had been originally presented to the desk; overruled

Printed Page 1340, Feb. 26

out of order in that it was not germane to the bill;

sustained

Printed Page 1258, Feb. 24
Printed Page 1449, Feb. 26
Printed Page 1450, Feb. 26
Printed Page 2520, Apr. 22
Printed Page 3107, Apr. 29
Printed Page 3370, May 12
Printed Page 3617, May 14
Printed Page 3618, May 14

overruled

Printed Page 1274, Feb. 24
Printed Page 2372, Apr. 2
Printed Page 3204, Apr. 30
Printed Page 3434, May 12
Printed Page 3504, May 13
Printed Page 3576, May 14
Printed Page 3616, May 14
Printed Page 3666, May 19

members have the right to speak for or against an amendment and then vote the opposite of the position for which they declared to be speaking

Printed Page 1372, Feb. 26

members are not prohibited from speaking both for and against an amendment

Printed Page 1373, Feb. 26

out of order as it was improperly drawn since it had no sponsors; sustained

Printed Page 1437, Feb. 26

out of order in that it was identical to a previously tabled amendment; sustained

Printed Page 1616, Mar. 5

out of order in that a fiscal impact statement which was not attached, was not complete; overruled

Printed Page 2385, Apr. 2

out of order under House Rule 9.4 which states that proposed amendments must be typewritten and in the proper format for the computer system; overruled

Printed Page 3428, May 12

Appropriations Bill Amendments

out of order under House Rule 5.3(B) in that it affected the appropriations of funds of more than five million dollars and that there was no corresponding reduction to cover this expense;

sustained

Printed Page 1697, Mar. 9

overruled

Printed Page 1749, Mar. 9

out of order in that it attempted to make a change to permanent law; overruled

Printed Page 1748, Mar. 9

out of order in that it was not germane to the bill and was out of order under House Rule5.3 (B); overruled

Printed Page 1821, Mar. 10

out of order under House Rule 5.4; overruled

Printed Page 1833, Mar. 10

out of order in that it was not germane to the bill;

overruled

Printed Page 1864, Mar. 10
Printed Page 1886, Mar. 10

sustained

Printed Page 1867, Mar. 10

Appropriation Bill Section

Out of order in that it was not germane to the bill; overruled

Printed Page 1740, Mar. 9

Bill

out of order as improperly before the House for consideration since its number and title had not been printed in the House Calendar at least one statewide legislative day prior to second reading; sustained

Printed Page 778, Jan. 15
Printed Page 935, Feb. 4
Printed Page 959, Feb. 5
Printed Page 960, Feb. 5
Printed Page 963, Feb. 5
Printed Page 1124, Feb. 12
Printed Page 1125, Feb. 12
Printed Page 1126, Feb. 12
Printed Page 1222, Feb. 19
Printed Page 1223, Feb. 19
Printed Page 1224, Feb. 19
Printed Page 1225, Feb. 19
Printed Page 1226, Feb. 19
Printed Page 1227, Feb. 19
Printed Page 1427, Feb. 26
Printed Page 1586, Mar. 5
Printed Page 1588, Mar. 5
Printed Page 1589, Mar. 5
Printed Page 1591, Mar. 5
Printed Page 1593, Mar. 5
Printed Page 1594, Mar. 5
Printed Page 2042, Mar. 25
Printed Page 2080, Mar. 26
Printed Page 2081, Mar. 26
Printed Page 2082, Mar. 26
Printed Page 2083, Mar. 26
Printed Page 2235, Apr. 1
Printed Page 2238, Apr. 1
Printed Page 2240, Apr. 1
Printed Page 2260, Apr. 1
Printed Page 2262, Apr. 1
Printed Page 2345, Apr. 2
Printed Page 2346, Apr. 2
Printed Page 2347, Apr. 2
Printed Page 2825, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2826, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2828, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2829, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2830, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2831, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2832, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2836, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2838, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2839, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2840, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2841, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2842, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2843, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2844, Apr. 23
Printed Page 3365, May 12
Printed Page 3366, May 12
Printed Page 3372, May 12
Printed Page 3373, May 12
Printed Page 3465, May 13
Printed Page 3651, May 19
Printed Page 3653, May 19
Printed Page 3655, May 19
Printed Page 3656, May 19
Printed Page 3657, May 19
Printed Page 3658, May 19

out of order in that the twenty-four hour point of order superseded all requests for debate or objections placed upon the bill and that all requests for debate on the bill should be removed with the bill retaining its place on the statewide uncontested calendar; overruled

Printed Page 961, Feb. 5

out of order under House Rule 5.13 in that a fiscal impact statement was required; overruled

Printed Page 1338, Feb. 26
Printed Page 2385, Apr. 2

out of order in that the bill as amended was now required to be referred to the Ways and Means Committee in order for an updated fiscal impact statement to be attached; overruled

Printed Page 2389, Apr. 2

Impeachment Resolution out of order in that an introduction of an impeachment resolution was not provided for as an acceptable subject matter under the Sine Die resolution; sustained

Printed Page 4335, Oct. 27

Joint Resolution

out of order as improperly before the House for consideration since its number and title had not been printed in the House Calendar at least one statewide legislative day prior to second reading; sustained

Printed Page 1122, Feb. 12
Printed Page 1124, Feb. 12
Printed Page 1223, Feb. 19
Printed Page 2084, Mar. 26
Printed Page 2261, Apr. 1
Printed Page 2267, Apr. 1
Printed Page 2348, Apr. 2
Printed Page 2559, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2560, Apr. 22
Printed Page 2833, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2834, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2839, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2841, Apr. 23
Printed Page 2844, Apr. 23
Printed Page 3371, May 12
Printed Page 3373, May 12

Motion

to recommit the bill to the Judiciary Committee was out of order since five members had already requested debate on the bill prior to the motion to recommit being made; sustained

Printed Page 1005, Feb. 10

to reject the slate of nominees was out of order; overruled

Printed Page 3470, May 13

to commit the bill to the Medical, Military, Public and Municipal Affairs Committee was out of order; sustained

Printed Page 4085, May 21

to recede until 4:00 p.m. was out of order; sustained

Printed Page 4086, May 21

Senate Amendments out of order as improperly before the House for consideration since its number and title had not been printed in the House Calendar at least one statewide legislative day prior to second reading; sustained

Printed Page 3228, Apr. 30
Printed Page 3667, May 19
Printed Page 3670, May 19
Printed Page 4039, May 21

Vote

out of order since the results of the vote had not been tabulated in accordance with Rule 7.3b; overruled

Printed Page 1438, Feb. 26

Last Updated: Thursday, March 11, 2010 at 3:37 P.M.